2 nd International Planetary Probe Workshop

Moffett Field, CA, USA

Aug. 24, 2004

CO

(

0

CD

1

( —

O

CO

— s

Q_

O

Q_

CD

£

O

Q_

03

CD

0

CL

13

CL

LU

O

CD

d

zy>

0

(

CO

cd

Q_

T3

O

cd

0

Q.

o3

_Q

cd

a5

Q_

O

0

Q_

CD

O

>

CD

O

"O

CD

O

CD

-*— *

E

Cd

CD

cd

"O

cb

=5

0

z

A

cl

w

O-

CO

E

CD

CO

>

CO

^ v

Q

Q_

^ ^

CO

O

E

£

03

cd

CO

0

>

>

CO

■0

O

cd

0

E

CO

cd

cd

>

c

Q_

0

0

CD

0

0

0

03

cd

0

E

CD

CO

CD

E

03

1

0

03

CD

00

' — '

"cd

>

CO

O

O

E

cd

c

0

CO

0

_£=

CO

0

Q_

O

■?

Q_

O

Q_

Q_

O

CO

1—

C

O

0

0

O

CD

03

cd

cd

03

"O

CD

c

0

CO

CO

0

Q_

1

03

O

O

cd

>

-0

'll

X

<

♦

♦

♦

CL

CO

CD

_o

0

Q?

cd

CL

1—

CO

0

CO

0

_o

E

0

cd

0)

CO

_o

CO

0

Q.

03

lo

>s

CO

O

Q.

"O

03

<D CO

^ CD

Id

E

CD

cd

“O

O h-
Q- CL

CO

0

CD ~
CL

cd

0

0

>

2 £

co t/J ~
~ CD

CD

0

1 —

O

2

T3 CL

O

♦

cd ♦

z

CL

•

•

CO

Id

_cd

CO

a;

'cd

>

cd

d

>

0

03

E

a3

E

0

d

CD

0

cd

c

0

0

CO

cd

"0

0

CO

CO

Q_

CD

X

"O

LU

cd

CD

03

O

CD

cd

Sta "

CO

Q_

E

Si

CO

0

0

0

03

03

>

1 —

CD

CO

"O

O

03

(

cd

CD

0

E

O

“O

O

CO

03

cd

0

CD

CD

CO

>

CO

CO

>

O

cd

Q_

_d

cd

cd

0

CO

0

0

03

O

0

CD

a3

cd

E

0

O

o3

CL

i.

d

♦

♦

O

<

H I

•

CO

cd

f

CsJ

00

o

o

o

CNJ

0

'q_

co

od

0

03

c

o

CO

0

0

o

Q_

s_

Z

CL

c

o

'(/)

0

o

0

b

o

0

c

0
'0
'o
0
Q

1

0

s_

CL

c^-

O) r\.

o g>

in a?

o> o

E O

o u>

CL .£

CD

O OQ

C CD
Cd Q_

O >*

c/) *“

CD C

O

Pre-Decisional -- For Discussion Purposes Only Thomas R. Spilker 2004/08/24

Fission-Powered Vehicle

CD

O

Q.

O

O

_cd

CD

"O

a;

as

a3

c=

CD

CJ)

i

CD

lQ CD

IB

CD

X

-Q

cd

_Q

O

CO

o

o

o

CD

O- § S 5

_Q

cd

Q_

cd

o

>

cd

a>

Q_

c= o

O Q-

o
o
o

CO

cl CD

_co Q

I I

O

aj

o

co

a) _cd

CO 02

>> cd

C/2 —

- §

cd

CD

Q_ ^ <Q

o g> c

^ CD
O P

(= a. S

CD

O-
CO
* — I

o

CsJ

I

O) CO

_o

~aS

D)

£

CO

c=

O)

CO

CD

"O

^ i o

#$■

CO

CD

LQ

o

Q.

>

CD

CD

Q.

=5

O

as

o_

co

E

■O
CO

o

>
CO

O) ♦

CO

as

o

Thomas R. Spilker 2004/08/24

How Are Mission Opportunities Changing?

C /3

CD

03

O

&

CO

CD

CD

E

o

cl

H — >

o

o

cl

<d

cl

o Hz

"O
CD
CO
a3
_Q

03

a3

CD

>

cd

"O

cd

o

CD

Q

I

>

CO

—

CD

1 q

=5

CO

cd

"O

CD

O

CO

cd

H t

o

a

"c=

CD

E

o

Q-

52

O

>

-Q

CD

>

CD

"O

"O

CD

O

C=

CD

O

52

>

lE

-Q

■ ~ ~

"O

X

CD

i — 1

O

cd

a

Q-

CD

X

c=

o

>

CO

CD

>

>

cd

" j *

CD

O

sz

CD

CO

92

O

CD

O

o

c

1—

CD

Q-

'o

CD

CO

3

"O

o

CD

CO

-C

o

92

CO

1 ■

sz

o

O

*

CL

LL

•

•

CO

£Z

o

co

CO

CD

H — >

i= o

:9 ^

$ Q.

cd q_

j03

"cd o
.<=> t/5

o

03

H — >

CO

03

03

cd

cd

03

CO

03

03

Q_

O

Q_

S^_

o

L— .

CD

O

Q.

-Q

CO

C=

o

cd

co

JD

Q-

E

cd

x

CD

in

_CD

=5

"O

CD

O

CO

O ^

Q- lo

o "<fl
03^ 2
O LL

cl #

CL

CL

-Q

a5

c

o

o

CO

-a

_CD

-Q

cd

O CD

CO CO
CO —
•= CD

E g

o .92

CD

y=

cd

o

CO

fd o

.<2 _c=

-c

CO

aT

.92

Q-

o

co

co

^ <

52

cd

CO

co

CD

o

c

cd

co

CD

CO

Q_

CO

CO

CD

c

o

o

c

o

cd

c=

CD

co

.92

cd

CD

td

CO

CD

CO

Q_

c

o

cd

Cl

CD

E

.92

Q_

CL

CL

92

Q_

cd

CD

o

c

92

o

CO

a5

cd

CD

O)

o

o

CD

Q_

CO

o

CO

E

cd

03

o

cl

C/3

03

CD

CO

£=

o

"co

CO

C/3

C/3

- t— »

o

Q_

03

£

0

I

1

o

CL

o

03

"o

CL

E

cd

03

o

CL

CO

a5

H— ^

c Z

CD c

O CD
“ CD
03 ^

fc £

o
o
co

Q

o

H »

T3

cd

a5

a;

to

GO

Q-

CO

O

cd

OD

c=

_cd

Q-

I

cd

GO

CD

a3

.92

Q-

E

cd

x

LU

CD

-Q

■q.

Cd

O

CD

M

GO

c=

o

CO

CO

cd

co

CD

o

^cd

<

GO

<

Pre-Decisional -- For Discussion Purposes Only Thomas R. Spilker 2004/08/24

Missions Of Interest a Year Ago

co

_cd

o

CD

>

cd “aT
« 1

Q_

CO

o

cd

CD

_>

o

>

>

o

CD

cd

o

co

a3

CD

LU

CO

>

CO

-I— >

Q_

CD

O

a>
o

CL

o ^

0 LU

1 |

co _E

P CO

CD

E

o

CO

I

CD

>

cd

cd

■a

T3

c

cd

o

co

a3

CD

CL

O

CL

co

CD

-Q

O

^ CL

-E CD
CD

DC -£

_oj O

E

cd J?
CO °-

3 E
c Q_

CD

>

CD

Q_

CD

O

£Z

O

o

c

o

CO

CO

o

CO

>

<

CO

<

CO

CD

_Q

O

aj

IE

-5. °

X CD

LU C

§ Q-
CD

"O

"O

CO

£=

CD

CO

CD

"O

H — >

£Z

cd

o

CD

CO

CD

_Q

O

Q_

CD

■a

cd _q

JE 2

CD CL

'E £

CO o

& I

o CD

c <

O (/)
O 3

5— C

CD CD

5 *

I

co

o

CD

>

CD
CO

£ o

"O

o

o

_cd

LU

o

O)

CT

as

CO

Pre-Decisional -- For Discussion Purposes Only Thomas R. Spilker 2004/08/24

CD

0>

c7)

O "O

o 3

D)(/)

CD 5

§

c/> £

(/)

(/)

to

o_

O

cb

"O

CD

c:

<D O

> o

f— CNJ

o

o

CNJ

CNJ

<

CO CNJ

)= T3
^ CD

co -c

CD E
> p

CO

"cd

“O

cd

o

CD

Q

E

o

cn

CD

c=

_cd

CL

&

O

"O

o 8

+-» (D
8 00

"O -3d

CD
O

a;

Q-

cd

o

CO

I

cd

x

LU

CO

CD

CO

"a

CD

CO

cd

co

CD

^ CD

^ .<=>

ij=

O
co

.2 E

co w
'<= o

"a

CD

o

cd

>

"O

<

CO

CD

"CD

E

o

cL

o

'o

CO

c=

o

CO

CO

o

o

-Q

cd

CO

c=

o

CO

o

CD

Q

>

_Q

■O

CD

^ o —

<

CO

<

os

CD

"O

cd

E

CD

cd

CO

CD

CD

E

o

□I

E

cd

CD

h-

a3

CD

o

CO

CD

CO

E

a5

cd

CD

c=

o

>

"O

a;

JD

Q_

CO

o

c

cd

_cd

_Q

cd

o

Q_

Q_

cd

o

CD

"O

a;

a5

"O

co

c

o

o

cd

CD

O

u

o

CD

Q.

>

_Q

^c/T

>

_Q

00

CD

CD

03

cd

00

=3

>>>

o

CD

lo

"a

c

"O

O

CD

E

03

"O

o

O

t/^

CD

Q_

o

i—

CD

"a

CD

E

jn^

o

cd

o

o

~3

E^

Q_

CD

p

CD

CD

P

CD

cd

"O

CD

CD

CO

o

o

5^

CO

a

o

CD

CD

o

o

Q_

Q_

T3

CO

CO

cd

CO

CD

'o

i »

♦

♦

♦

GO

•

•

CD

CO

o

cd

Q_

o

"a3

o

co

o

a;

□I

_cd

to

a3

CD

CT

_CD

Q_

E

cd

CO

o

'c

CD

CD

O

o

CD

E

o

O

CO

CD

_Q

O

Q-

CD

CD

_>

O

>

Id

CD

-i— »

O

Q_

-i— »

CO

CD

CD

cr

_CD
Q_

E
cd
CO

"O

c
cd

co

o
>

INI
CD
"O
C
CD

cr

"O

o
a5
00
<

CD

o. fc=

^ o

Q-

O

O

CO

CO

CO

NT

CNJ

00

O

O

o

CNJ

0

'q_
c n

cd

c/)

03

0
0
o

1

0

s_

CL

Saturn entry probes; Titan mobile surface/atmospheric platform (aerobot?)
Neptune (also, Uranus) entry probes; Triton lander?

Galileo-Style (Conventional) Probe Delivery

CD

CD

_Q

O

Q_

CD

O

"cd

_Q

CO

o

cC

a5

>

CD

CO

O

cC

o

Q-

Q.

CT5

E

1q

o 6

i i

Pre-Decisional -- For Discussion Purposes Only Thomas R. Spilker 2004/08/24

Galileo-Style Probe Support

Pre-Decisional -- For Discussion Purposes Only Thomas R. Spilker 2004/08/24

How Entry Probe Delivery
From an NEP Vehicle Is Different

o

s

o

5

4 — >

Cl

0

4 — >

01

C

£

o

c

o

00
h — .

OS

Cl

E

o

O

o

I —

0

>“

m ik
!

(m)A

co

^ CD

££

(A—

CD CD

■-£= CD
C Dct ^

E Cd

O

o

cd

o

Q.

Q.

CTS

co

co

’F °

E a3 £
o > -9
>,2

> a 3 _^

S ^8

> cd o
:= Q cd

Q #

I

Q_

cd

o

CD

CD-B .9

CD

_oT

cd

cd

cd

"O

_cd

-Q

cd

c

CD

3 £

<8 .9

c 1
cd -5

o m

c

0

0

c

0

vu —

0

s^_

o

TD

C

0

C O
0

0 0 CO

<2, P C

0

0 .9

0
0
O
c
0
0
ID

0 0
CD-Q

0 2

_l CL

I

?§8

■ ■ c

3

0

°-5

5 a ;

Cd .Inf
O _Q

E o

CD CD
_Q

O ^

&-§

.55

05 ^

#E

05 CD
O)

!> cd

O 0
o 0
0 0
0
0 t -

±z O

c •—

'<0 g 1 ^

CD ■== CO
CD ^ —
C 3 0
co -o
■5 °_-o

° c CD

0 .^'5

'co $ cr

2 -g £

1

"O

c
>, CO
CO -*-*

■ fl 5 W

2 o

o

co ^

"co £ co

0 ~ c

^ ^ o.
05-2 CD

1 Sf

E

33 =j o
< CO o
I

How Entry Probe Delivery
From an NEP Vehicle Is Different

-Q

O

_Cd

=5

O

'o

i

cd

CD

cd

o

_cd

"cd

Q_

O

Q_

"O

CD

Q_

x.+n

CD _q

CO

O

O

(D

a5

>

~_Q

c:

o

CO

CD

CD

O"

CD

>

i

cd

"cd

^ CD
(D^)
0)0
cd o.
co ^

co c:
o CD

2" CD

~ O Q_ -E-

Q #

I

g*

c=

CD

g

CO

>

I

cd
"a5

"O

cd _

S> e

cc

>

I

cd

"a5

"O

co

CD

co

cd

CD

o>

. o
cd
c o
"cd E Q-
Id cd"

^ o_ c=

00 co\°
S c o

i_ CD ^
CD ~

E 5 ^ S

iS 2 o3
<Q

Lq cB
o|8

O CD

LL Q__Q

CD

M

CO

O

_C= CD

a3

^ tfc=

^ CD
co ■-!=:
■— o

CO O"

^ -Q
2 C
-J-; Cd

Lq °

CO
CD

o

cd

o

co

CD

cd

8-g

CD =3

= g*

Z) cd

Pre-Decisional -- For Discussion Purposes Only Thomas R. Spilker 2004/08/24

How Entry Probe Delivery
From an NEP Vehicle Is Different

-Q

O

O

CD

O

O

CD

cd

o

_cd

"a5

Q_

O

Q_

"O

CD

Q_

x.+n

CD _q

GO

O

O

CD

c

o

U2

c=

CD

E

CD

O"

CD

>

i

cd

a; o_
cd

^ ^ CD =

a3 Lq-T

> ^ c=

— O a (/) cd
oj .

Q

I

"cd

a

CD

Q_

CD

_CD

"cd

E

CO

CD

CD CD
Q-.tzi

O "2

CD

0

E

CD

_CD

-Q

'CO ^
CO _C=

o

OL) CO

>

■ ■ i

cd

CD

"O

CD ^

^ c

0 O
-Q '■

1 CL

E o

0 r

co E
o_

0 o

° it
0-3

< 0

1

'^3 CD

cd

O "O

e 1

CD

_Q $D

o O

^ ^ ^

CD

o

c

cd

to

T3

CO

CD

"O

CD -^=

cd

-Q

0

1

<u

_D

0

01

•

a)

_Q

CD

c

o

(0

CD

0

T3

O) 0 0
cd Z '43

_c

!5

x

0

M—

■a

0

$ to

2 o

o ^

C 0

— o

>> o

-I— >

0

0 -b

5 S

Pre-Decisional -- For Discussion Purposes Only Thomas R. Spilker 2004/08/24

Still, many future opportunities for entry probe missions

co

o

cd

co

CD

TD

"cd

CD

o

Q_

cd

■a

CD

CD

c

cd

o

CD

jl

CO

o

CO

CO

'E

CD

CD

E

a;

o_

E

cd

co

CD
>
'h — >

o

Lq

o

CD

o

CD

'o

co

>

d

cd

I

co

E

co

cd

o

CD

E

_CD

_Q

cd

'cd

>

<

I

CO

CD

cd

■a

c

cd

co

a3

CD

CD

CD

CD

JQ

CL

cd

O

cd

>

o

cd

o

CD

_o

o

o

CD

_cd

cd

o

CD

_o

o

CD

CO

CD

O

Q_

Q_

o

"O

CD

H — >

CO

cd

X

CD

d

CD

CD

_Q

co

cd

o

Q_

Q_

CO

■a

cd

a3

>

"a5

“O

CD

o

cd

o_

co

CD

CO

CD

Q

I

CO

o

cd

"O

CD

CD

CO

=5

"O

CD

SI

C=

O

c=

o

'cd

CO

_Q

CD

CD

=5

C

cd

CD

CO

>

cd

cd

CD

>

c

cd

■a

O

♦

♦

"O

CD

a5

"cd

cd

o

CD

'co

CO

CO

CD

_>

CD

CO

E

CD

CO

_a;

o

CD

>

CD

0

CD

CO

CD

Cl

1

_Q

cd

Q_

cd

o

>

cd

"a5

■a

CD

0
cd

Q_

CO

1

■a

■o

cd

_oj

_Q

co

co

o

Q_

Q_

CD

O

X

CD

CD

d

o

I

a)

s_

CL

Realizing missions requires significant community consensus about
mission objectives